Our Menu

FROZEN CUSTARD, PIES & MORE!

 

Frozen Custard

FLAVORS: CHOCOLATE, VANILLA, BUTTER PECAN & TODAY’S SPECIAL FLAVOR

  • Baby Cup:  $2.66

  • Single Cone:  $3.75

  • Double Cone:  $4.75

  • Triple Cone:  $5.75

  • Single Waffle Cone:  $4.40

  • Double Waffle Cone:  $5.40

  • Triple Waffle Cone:  $6.40

 

Fresh Custard to Go!

PINT     $6.25


QUART     $12.00

 

SPECIALTY SUNDAES

SUNDAE OF BROKEN DREAMS     $6.75
Vanilla Frozen Custard topped with caramel sauce, covered in Pretzel Crunch & fresh whipped cream    


SHORTCAKE CRUMBLE SUNDAE    $6.75
Salty, Sweet Shortcake Crumbles, Vanilla Frozen Custard, Door County strawberry compote & fresh whipped cream 


SNOWBALL INFERNO SUNDAE    $6.95
Molten Door County Cherries, Vanilla Frozen Custard covered in a Magical Chocolate Shell & topped with fresh whipped cream


EL NINO SUNDAE    $7.15
Chocolate Frozen Custard, covered in hot fudge and red raspberries, topped with fresh whipped cream 


OUR FAMOUS TURTLE SUNDAE     $7.15
Vanilla Frozen Custard, hot fudge, hot caramel and covered with our AMAZING pecans


DOOR COUNTY SUNDAE    $7.15
Vanilla Frozen Custard, hot fudge & Door County Cherries covered with our AMAZING pecans 


STRAWBERRY BANANA SPLIT    $7.50
3 scoops of Vanilla Frozen Custard, a whole banana, drenched in strawberry compote, topped with fresh whipped cream 


CHUNKY MONKEY SUNDAE    $5.95
Chocolate Frozen Custard, banana & covered in peanut butter topping 


BROWNIE SUNDAE     $7.15
A warm chocolate brownie, Vanilla Frozen Custard & hot fudge


MIDNIGHT OREO™ SUNDAE    $5.70
Chocolate Frozen Custard, drenched in marshmallow topping & covered with Oreo™ cookies


FLOATING HOT FUDGE SUNDAE    $6.70
Swirls of hot fudge Floating in Vanilla Frozen Custard & topped with fresh whipped cream 


YANKEE SNICKERDOODLE-DOO SUNDAE    $6.75
Clay Clop’s browned butter Snickerdoodle cookies sandwiching a large scoop of Vanilla Frozen Custard, covered in hot caramel 


PUDGY BUNNY SUNDAE    $5.95
A nest of Oreo™ cookies, Chocolate Frozen Custard, covered in a Magical Chocolate Shell, bunny ears & a special bunny friend 


DO YOU WANT TO BUILD A SNOWMAN SUNDAE    $5.95
Vanilla Frozen Custard “Olaf” standing in a melted puddle of blue moon topping, comes with a warm hug 


COOKIES ‘N’ CREAM    $6.75
Clay Clop’s browned butter M&M chocolate chip cookies sandwiching a large scoop of your choice of Frozen Custard covered in hot fudge 

 

SUNDAES

SMALL SINGLE TOPPING SUNDAE     $5.15


LARGE SINGLE TOPPING SUNDAE     $6.15

TOPPINGS:

Chocolate Sauce • Strawberry • Hot Cherry • Red Raspberry • Hot Fudge • Hot Caramel • Marshmallow • Strawberry Rhubarb • Honey • Maple Syrup • Salted Caramel


Extra Toppings:

Brownie, Cashews, Whipped Cream, Sprinkles, Pecans, Clay Clop’s Cookie

 

EDIBLE COOKIE DOUGH


DAILY FLAVORS
Small Sundae     
$6.15

Regular Malt     $6.85
Large Sundae     $7.15

Large Malt     $8.70

Pint      $7.75

 
Not_Licked_Yet_Exterior_7_share.jpg

SUZY Q’S SLICE OF HEAVEN PIE

SLICE      $5.25

A LA MODE     $6.85
WHOLE PIE      $26.00

 

GOIN’ BANANAS

SCREAMING BANANA     $3.95
Tastes like custard but made purely from bananas!   


FROZEN CHOCOLATE DIPPED BANANAS      $2.50

 

FRESH FRUIT ICE POPS

MADE WITH SEASONAL FRUIT      $3.00

 

CHAR-BROILED SANDWICHES

WE USE LOCAL GRASS FED BEEF SERVED ON OUR FRESHLY BAKED YEASTY BUNS

POTATO CHIPS     $1.50


HAMBURGER      $6.50


DOUBLE HAMBURGER      $9.95


CHEESEBURGER      $6.80


DOUBLE CHEESEBURGER      $10.75


BACON CHEESEBURGER      $7.75


WILD DRAGON BURGER      $8.25
3 pepper hot dragon sauce, jalapeños, lettuce, red onion, Habañero jack cheese & pickles 


GET IN MY BELLY BURGER     $8.25
Honey bacon, lettuce, bread & butter pickles, cheddar cheese & yummy ranch parmesan sauce 


DOOR COUNTY BRATWURST      $6.80


SKINLESS ALL BEEF FOOT LONG HOT DOG      $4.25


BACON LETTUCE & TOMATO      $5.50


GRILLED HAM & RENARD’S CHEDDAR CHEESE SANDWICH      $5.95


ALL NATURAL GRILLED CHICKEN SANDWICH      $7.95
Topped with Lettuce & Mayo


HULA SANDWICH     $6.75
Grilled ham, mozzarella cheese, sun dried tomato pesto & grilled pineapple 


-----------


Burger Toppings (Free):
Catsup, pickle slices, mayo, onions, Ranch, 1000 Island


Other Toppings (Additional charge):
Lettuce, Tomato, Fried Onions, Bacon, Mozzarella, Cheddar, Cherry Chutney, American Cheese, Gluten free bun or bread, Jalapeños

 

TASTY HOT SANDWICHES

PIZZA PANINI      $4.95
Pepperoni, pizza sauce, oregano and fresh Mozzarella cheese grilled, on freshly baked bread 


FISH REUBEN       $8.15
Whitefish, 1000 Island dressing, coleslaw & Mozzarella cheese paninied on freshly baked bread 


GRILLED AMERICAN CHEESE PANINI      $3.75

 

FRESH SANDWICHES

ANGRY OGRE      $8.25
Grilled chicken breast with lettuce, tomato, red onion Mozzarella cheese & cherry chutney on freshly baked bread 

TROLL CLUB      $8.25
Grilled chicken breast, bacon, mayo, lettuce and tomato on freshly baked bread


ASPARAGUS CAPRESE SANDWICH      $6.95
Freshly grilled asparagus, mozzarella cheese, tomato, basil pesto
lettuce blend served on freshly baked bread. Vegetarian Selection


COLD HAM AND AMERICAN CHEESE SANDWICH       $4.65
on freshly baked bread


GARDEN SANDWICH     $6.25
Lettuce, tomato, red onion, Mozzarella cheese, sweet peppers, cucumber & cherry chutney served on freshly baked bread. Vegetarian Selection

 

THIRST QUENCHERS

CONCRETE, SUPER THICK MALT OR SHAKE

Chocolate • Vanilla • Strawberry • Hot Cherry • Red Raspberry • Banana

  • Strawberry Rhubarb • Honey • Maple Syrup • Salted Caramel

  • Regular     $5.65

  • Large      $6.50

ROOT BEER FLOAT       $4.25


SODA: 
Coke, Diet Coke, 7up, Root Beer, Sun Drop, Dr. Pepper

  • Small $1.75

  • Medium $1.95

  • Large $2.15


ICE TEA (16 oz)       $2.60

LICKITY DELICIOUS LEMONADE (16 oz)      $2.60


ICED COFFEE      $3.50

  • Mocha, Caramel, Vanilla 

DOOR COUNTY HOT COFFEE       $2.00


HOT APPLE CIDER       $2.60

HOT COCOA (16 oz)      $3.25


MILK      $1.60


BOTTLED WATER      $1.25

 

ORDER AND PICKUP AT THE COUNTER... THANKS

CONSUMING RAW OR UNDERCOOKED MEAT OR CHICKEN MAY INCREASE THE CHANCE OF FOOD BORNE ILLNESS


ADD 5.5% SALES TAX • PRICES SUBJECT TO CHANGE

 

920-868-2617

4054 Main St
Fish Creek, Wisconsin 54212

©2020 Not Licked Yet