Hours
Open seven days a week – April through October
11:30 a.m - close
Title
At Not Licked Yet Frozen Custard, freshness is everything. This is a family business and in this family we do not settle for second best. We prepare all our food from the finest natural ingredients available, using farm fresh locally produced fruits and vegetables, along with locally raised grass fed beef.
Our custard is made in front of your eyes, every bite of its velvety smooth texture and creamy flavor makes a little party in your mouth.
Of course our cookies and desserts are always just out of the oven, warm and tasty, the best brownies you will ever taste!! Suzy Q is baking her Amazing mouth watering pies!! .
We bake our buns and bread daily using old fashioned slow-rising dough.
We offer many delicious vegetarian, gluten free and dairy free options along with our unique delicious burgers. Our kitchen also offers a variety of delicious hot and cold sandwiches and Paninis that will appeal to the kid inside all of us.
We have outdoor dining along our spectcular shoreline. Have fun on our GIANT playground - child tested, Mama and Papa approved. Wander along our beautiful meandering Fish Creek where Door County wildlife mixes with our beautiful Door County landscape. Evenings stroll along the twinkling lighted paths under the moonlit sparkling stars.
Come inside and enjoy our cozy fireside dining room or dine on our heated patios or relax on rocking chairs scattered along the waterfront while savoring your favorite custard delight.
Always ample parking and we stay open late for food and custard.
Header Title
Header Subtitle
List Item Title
Item Subtitle
This is your item description. Use this space to add a description of the services, products, team members or any other items you want to highlight on your site. Have a lot to say? Easily turn any item into a full page by clicking ‘Create a page from this item’ in the edit panel.
List Item Title
Item Subtitle
This is your item description. Use this space to add a description of the services, products, team members or any other items you want to highlight on your site. Have a lot to say? Easily turn any item into a full page by clicking ‘Create a page from this item’ in the edit panel.
List Item Title
Item Subtitle
This is your item description. Use this space to add a description of the services, products, team members or any other items you want to highlight on your site. Have a lot to say? Easily turn any item into a full page by clicking ‘Create a page from this item’ in the edit panel.
Contact
4054 Main St
Fish Creek, Wisconsin 54212
920-868-2617
Order for Pick Up!

Decadent Dessert
From $3

Assorted Toppings
From $5

Raspberry Delight
From $6
FROZEN CUSTARD, PIES & MORE!
​
FROZEN CUSTARD
FLAVORS: CHOCOLATE, VANILLA, BUTTER PECAN & TODAY’S SPECIAL FLAVOR
Baby Cup
Single, Double, or Triple Cone
Single, Double, or Triple Waffle Cone
FRESH PACKED CUSTARD TO GO!!
Pint
Quart
SUZY’S PIE - SUZY Q’S SLICE OF HEAVEN PIE
Slice
A la mode
Whole pie
SCREAMING BANANA
Tastes like ice cream, but made purely from bananas!
FROZEN CHOCOLATE DIPPED BANANAS
​
FRESH FRUIT ICE POPS
Menu
Frozen Custard Flavors
CHOCOLATE • VANILLA • BUTTER PECAN • TODAY’S SPECIAL FLAVOR
Fresh Packed Custard To Go
Pint
Quart
SUZY Q’S SLICE OF HEAVEN PIE
Slice
A la mode
Whole pie
SCREAMING BANANA
Tastes like ice cream, but made purely from bananas!
FROZEN CHOCOLATE DIPPED BANANAS
​
FRESH FRUIT ICE POPS
​
THIRST QUENCHERS
CONCRETE, SUPER THICK MALT OR SHAKE
Chocolate, Vanilla, Coffee, Strawberry, Hot Cherry, Raspberry, Banana, Strawberry Rhubarb, Honey, Maple Syrup, Salted Caramel
​
FLOATS
​
Root Beer
SODA
​
Coke, Diet Coke, 7UP, Root Beer, Sun Drop, Dr. Pepper
​
FRESHLY BREWED ICE TEA
​
LICKITY DELICIOUS LEMONADE
​
ICED COFFE
Mocha, Caramel, Vanilla
DOOR COUNTY COFFEE
with 1 free refill
HOT APPLE CIDER
Service Subtitle
HOT COCOA
Supreme or Caramel
MILK
​
Bottled Water
​
FROZEN CHOCOLATE DIPPED BANANAS
​
​
CHAR-BROILED SANDWICHES
WE USE LOCAL GRASS FED BEEF
SERVED ON FRESHLY BAKED YEASTY BUNS
RACHEL’S KETTLE CHIPS
​
HAMBURGER
​
CHEESEBURGER
​
DOUBLE HAMBURGER
​
DOUBLE CHEESEBURGER
​
BACON CHEESEBURGER
​
WILD DRAGON BURGER
3 pepper hot dragon sauce, jalapeños, lettuce, red onion & pickles
GET IN MY BELLY BURGER
Honey bacon, lettuce, bread & butter pickles, cheese crisps & Ranch Parmesan sauce
DOOR COUNTY BRATWURST
​
Greetings from Not Licked Yet Frozen Custard in beautiful Fish Creek. We will be opening for our 37th season on Thursday May 28, 2020. We are very excited!. We have closed are the inside dining room for the near future, but no worries we have extended our dining area across our entire property. We have socially distanced more tables, chairs and umbrellas and expanded our heaters throughout our property. We have lots of new flavors this year and can not wait to see all old and new customers. Our hours are 11:30 - 9:00 and will extend as we are into our summer season. We look forward to seeing you.
Menu
simple list
Our Products
On the Shelves

Decadent Dessert
From $3

Assorted Toppings
From $5

Raspberry Delight
From $6